Movie Clips
A few weeks ago a friend emailed me to ask my opinion on his use of movie clips in a series of Bible lessons to young adults. He was privy to certain recent discussions of Christian postmodernism (including some more vigorous ones that went outside this blog), and wanted to know how I felt about using video in Christian education. (Christian Education: that term ought to irk the emergent bloggers.) Here, roughly, is what I said:
You may or may not ever find me doing a multimedia lesson including actual movie clips, but I don’t condemn the practice outright. That is, I’m not nuts about it, but everybody does it, and I don’t think it’s fatal or anything.Technology, particularly technology used for entertainment purposes, is almost literally ubiquitous in our lives. It is far too pervasive for most of us to have much perspective on it. (As they say, if you want to know what water is, don’t ask a fish–and baby, we’re technological fish.) I can’t say I’ve thought enough about this to be able to prove coercively all of the hidden assumptions and ideas that using PowerPoint to project our lesson outline or Media Player to watch a movie clip brings into a teaching environment, but I fear the unexamined assumptions that entertainment technology probably brings along for the ride when we try to harness it for our purposes. My judgment is that they will usually do some kind of harm–a kind most people are ignoring–so I personally try to avoid them most of the time.
And this from a technology professional!
My bent against the user of movie clips in teaching doesn’t have much to do with Postmodernism qua Postmodernism, although the general postmodern (and postmodernist) preference of Image over Word certainly comes into play. It’s more a matter of setting my goal to be engaging souls with ideas, and being cautious (perhaps overly so) of forcing people back into Entertainment Consumption mode instead. Certainly there are large advantages to using movie clips that should be weighed against this concern, and even more certainly, quality teaching shouldn’t be afraid to make appropriate cultural allusions. The sad fact of our lives is that movies and pop music are going to be pretty much the only cultural artifacts we are going to be able to draw on for almost all of the people to whom we minister. If I don’t like that, I might as well get mad at the wind for blowing, or the NEA for existing. Still, at the end of the day, I try to avoid the use of multimedia in teaching unless it matches the subject matter uniquely. (Like if we were studying film depictions of Christ, as in Philip Yancey’s Sunday School-productized The Jesus I Never Knew.)
I know and respect other people who have considered this question and deliberately decided against my approach and in favor of yours. I don’t do it myself, but it doesn’t bother me all that much when other people do. It is no big deal.
On the heels of this (and this was all in that hazy season of my life the few weeks before I left for Spain), I had the exciting opportunity to adapt an enterprise software architecture diagram to PowerPoint use. Now, you may be thinking that’s a simple matter of selecting the whole diagram in Visio, copying it to the clipboard, and pasting it in PowerPoint, but you’re only thinking that because you’re wrong. It has much more to do with figuring out how to present information PowerPoint-style, which consists chiefly in limiting your minimum text size to 18 points.
If you weren’t wondering why I thought it was so hard to get a block diagram into PowerPoint, you may be wondering what this has to do with using movie clips in Bible lessons. Answer: more than you might think. I’m going to try to give you more on this in the next week. Coming soon: Why PowerPoint Is The Devil.







