Science Lesson
Frustrated with all evangelical home school science curricula on the entire planet–the entire old planet, if you get my meaning–I have decided to make up my own. Yesterday was our first lesson.
We spent about twenty minutes discussing how it is we know about things. We identified revelation, observation, authority, and “reason” as sources of knowledge about things. We skipped intuition and probably a few other things, but this is elementary school, not undergraduate Intoduction To Epistemology, okay?
The kids seemed to appreciate the first lesson, and were able to think of examples of each category as I introduced them. Today we’ll talk more about the “reason” category, describing the difference between deduction and induction, and explain that induction is at the foundation of all science. I think the fourth grader will do okay with this. We’ll see about the first/second grader. (What are these grades, anyway? This is homeschool!)
In the cuteness department, the seven-year-old offered this definition of science before the lesson began:
You experiment stuff. Sometimes you do liquids, animals, places…magnets, lots of stuff.
Sometimes even stuff with food, you can do that.Science is just like sort of seeing what things are gonna look like and learning things about animals and stuff. And you can do it with rain sometimes. And maybe maps. You can do it with a lot of stuff.
Not half bad, really. We’ll see what she says in a month.
Don’t worry, we will get to actual science content at some point. Gotta start with some fundamentals, though.
And oh yeah, why don’t we just buy a non-evangelical science curriculum if all the young-earth irks me so badly? Because it’s expensive and does a poor job teaching the big picture. What I’ve seen typically has a perfunctory chapter teaching “The Scientific Method” with absolutely no context at all; that is, it does not explain in an age-appropriate manner the problem of how to know things, and how the scientific method attempts to answer this question. The book then launches into an oddly-organized flood of specific science content that itself does a bad job of building from first principles. Little kids can understand atoms and forces at a high level; why not start there?



