U.S.S. Credobaptist
I am a messy desk man. It gets pretty out of control sometimes, requiring a few hours to get it beat down into something more amenable to public health and morality. During a recent clean-up I found a note I had written in January, when my then-three-year-old daughter said a couple of very cute things in one day. The first was, “When I go to sleep at night, I have a movie in my eye.” Wonderfully self-aware, understandable, and cute. The second one requires some explanation, both from her and from me:
At dinner she said, “Now God is cold.”
She said this right after taking a drink of milk. I had to ask her what she meant, and she explained that God, who was “in her heart”–the same heart the milk had just passed on her way to her stomach, and eventually to her pee, as she was happy to explain–had now experienced a reduction in temperature. Note to armchair theologians: temperature is not a communicable attribute of God.
First of all, an admission: this is really cute. I can give the girl her due. She’s adorable. Innocent, after a fashion. Precious. Endearing.
But.
Maybe this does point out a minor problem with a certain children’s ministry to which my daughter was possibly exposed. (Note to readers who are IRL friends: she did not hear this at church.) Maybe the gospel was presented to a group of preschoolers that in a manner appropriate for older elementary students. Maybe the highly abstract language of “ask Jesus into your heart” is just a wee bit over the heads of quintessentially concrete-thinking little kids. Indeed, maybe kerygmatizing a room full of three-year-olds is not such a good idea after all.
You see, Reformed Baptists live in a muddle. Some of us have definite questions about the course our own ship is on, with some of the other crewmen in the Baptist Fleet passing out these things that vaguely resemble life vests, having the military jargon “Age Of Acc.” stenciled on them. Those same helpful sailors are paradoxically happy to help our little ones Ask Jesus Into Their Hearts as soon as they can speak, even though a toddler’s oath of allegiance to the Navy isn’t the most reliable elocutionary act in the history of the spoken word. To top it all off, the fleet’s regs don’t say a thing about young sailors who either haven’t sworn the oath or aren’t wearing that big, puffy, orange thing that we’re pretty sure is probably a flotation device of some kind. If they’re lost at sea, have we lost a fellow soldier, or just some passenger on the ship?
The H.M.S. Paedobaptist always seems to have one of its lifeboats in the wake of the U.S.S. Credo, ready to fish out jumpers and give them a lift to that neat, well-run, tightly disciplined ship in the nearby allied fleet. And without a doubt, there’s no other crew we’d rather put into port with than those guys on the Paedo. The other sailors from our fleet won’t ever have a drink with us (well, the older ones won’t), the Paedo guys seem to get our jokes more often, and they don’t wear as many of those goofy tee shirts as our shipmates do. They still expect their young seamen to swear fealty to the Navy when they’re old enough for it to make sense, but they never pretend that those garishly-colored down ski jackets are going to help any of the little ones float should they fall overboard. And about those young sailors: not all of the H.M.S. Padeo’s officers even agree on how to account for those who do fall in combat, but at least the whole ship agrees that they were assigned an official rank and serial number before the shooting started.
Still, enamored as some of the Credo sailors are of that tight ship with its well-written regs and orderly accounting for all hands, most of them continue to serve their own ship. Sure, those down jackets some of the guys keep talking about are absurd, but we still can’t get ourselves to take the plunge and swim for that other boat, despite having looked plaintively over that bow for many an evening. Well thought-out regulations are alluring, but we’ve been wrong before, and a system that is more inferential than necessary is potentially a recipe for being wrong again, or so we fear.
We are left, though, with some very odd training procedures for the youngest of our recruits. That, and with Sarah thinking that God can hear the pet cockatiel better when it sticks its head in her mouth and chirps. Too bad neither one of these ships really seems to be going in quite the right direction.
The good news is that these little sailors usually grow up, and the questions that apply in their youth become moot. We’ll get there, whether on one boat or the other.

